How businesses can build advantages that reinforce each other

undefined
Companies that want to ensure long-term success can no longer rely on having just one powerful advantage.Image: Unsplash/Startaê Team
  • Single competitive advantages are no longer enough for businesses to navigate today’s market volatility. But by combining more than one strategic advantage, organizations can protect long-term growth.

For much of business history, a single powerful advantage could carry a company for decades. Today, relying on one is increasingly risky. 

A new McKinsey study found that companies’ relative competitive positions were changing faster in more than 60% of industries over the past decade. AI could only intensify this pressure. 

In this environment, companies can become more resilient by building multiple advantages that reinforce one another, creating a system rivals find harder to emulate.

Five routes to strategic advantage

A strategic advantage is a reason a company can create, capture or protect more value than competitors. Not every worthwhile initiative creates a strategic advantage. To do so, it must give the company a distinctive reason to win.

Through research, teaching and work with companies, we have distilled five different routes to advantage. Together, they spell IDEAS. They build on established traditions in strategy, from competitive positioning and market creation to resources and capabilities, innovation and ecosystems.

  • Integrated positioning: aligning a company’s choices behind a superior cost position or a credible premium position.

  • Demand creation: activating customers, needs, or uses the market overlooks or serves poorly.

  • Ecosystem shaping: improving how participants around the business work together, so the wider system creates more value.

  • Asset activation: turning resources or capabilities that are hard to reproduce into profitable growth, stronger economics or greater defensibility.

  • Substitute innovation: replacing an accepted product, process, transaction or source of friction with a materially better alternative.

The framework has two uses: mapping the advantages a company already has and directing the search for the advantage it should build next.

When advantages reinforce one another

Seen through this lens, the power of combining these routes becomes clear in the contrasting trajectories of meal kit delivery pioneers HelloFresh and Blue Apron.

HelloFresh was founded in Berlin in late 2011; Blue Apron followed in New York in 2012. Both offered meal kits and ready-to-eat meals delivered to the door. By 2015, their revenues were nearly neck and neck: $340.8 million for Blue Apron and roughly $338 million for HelloFresh.

Both companies began with the exact same starting advantage: substitute innovation. However, their fortunes soon diverged. By 2022, Blue Apron reported about $458 million in revenue, whereas HelloFresh had surged to €7.6 billion.

The divergence becomes clear once we stop treating strategic advantage as singular. HelloFresh surrounded its original breakthrough by systematically building four additional advantages around it:

  • Integrated positioning: Coordinating planning, purchasing, forecasting, fulfillment, and delivery made the service more reliable and its economics stronger.

  • Demand creation: That reliability helped it reach broader customer groups and markets

  • Asset activation: Orders generated data and operating knowledge that sharpened future planning and forecasting.

  • Ecosystem shaping: Suppliers and logistics providers became integrated into a wider delivery network that competitors found hard to match.

Having several advantages gives a company more than one reason to win; if one area weakens, others can sustain the business. But HelloFresh’s advantages did more than coexist – they created a self-reinforcing flywheel. Scale generated data, data improved forecasting and efficiency, and greater efficiency attracted still more demand. The company managed to create a loop where each new advantage made the existing ones perform better.

Of course, a multi-layered system does not make a company immune to market shifts; but it does make it far more durable when headwinds arrive. In recent years, lower demand has weakened the scale benefits of HelloFresh’s fulfilment and operating efficiency, and the company’s share price has plunged from its 2021 peak. Yet even as market conditions toughened, its underlying operating profitability held up: core meal-kit profit margins actually expanded from 9.8% in 2024 to 13.5% in 2025. 

The ultimate test of a strategy is whether a company’s strengths amplify and protect one another through changing conditions. Recognizing such a reinforcing architecture in hindsight is easy; the managerial challenge is to build its next component before the answer becomes obvious.

Putting the framework into practice

Translating this concept into action requires shifting how executive teams generate and filter strategic choices. Rather than relying on incremental operational fixes, leaders can use the five routes to uncover hidden growth engines.

Consider Beaulieu Flooring Solutions, a Belgian flooring manufacturer that had already been sharpening its existing business with pricing, segmentation, and digital tools. But it wanted fresh routes to growth. 

In an IDEAS workshop, the Beaulieu leadership team generated 36 strategic options by looking beyond traditional product sales. One option focused on ecosystem shaping: rather than simply supplying synthetic turf for courts, could Beaulieu help clubs and communities promote padel – a fast-growing racket sport played on artificial turf – to expand the overall market? A second targeted asset activation by exploring the option of licensing high-speed digital printing technology developed for its own factories. A third applied substitute innovation, challenging the assumption that customers must buy temporary flooring outright rather than renting it as a service.

However, finding an opening is not the same as designing an effective strategy. Take the padel idea. Mobilizing clubs and communities could have expanded participation and created demand for courts, but Beaulieu would have needed a way to capture that additional demand for artificial grass. The workshop selected 15 options for further development, shelved six and dropped 15. The result was a wider set of possibilities and clearer priorities for what to develop next.

Proving the pattern across industries

Beaulieu was not an isolated case. Across seven cohorts involving 350 experienced executives, we conducted an initial open-ended strategy exercise and a subsequent exercise guided by the IDEAS framework. The latter produced almost seven times as many responses classified as strategic options. Operational improvements, initially about two-thirds of responses, fell to a handful.

These findings point to a practical blueprint for executive teams. To break out of incremental thinking and construct a system of reinforcing advantages, leaders drawing on the IDEAS framework should take these three steps to optimize their strategic options: 

  • Search across five distinct routes to uncover possibilities familiar habits might hide.

  • Strengthen promising options by asking what further advantage could make them more powerful.

  • Commit to moves with economic potential and reinforcing logic.

The goal is not to accumulate individual advantages or generate ever more initiatives. Rather, it is to design strategic moves that function as a mutually reinforcing system.

In an environment of constant disruption, the central strategic question is no longer simply where to compete, but which combination of advantages can create a durable, self-reinforcing reason to win.

License and Republishing
World Economic Forum articles may be republished in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International Public License, and in accordance with our Terms of Use. The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone and not the World Economic Forum.