Industries in Depth

These elements could disappear from the world

A sign showing titanium on the periodic table of elements is seen at the Nobel Biocare manufacturing facility in Yorba Linda, California May 16, 2013. Nobel Biocare Holding AG is trying to regain its initial success after seeing its profits and image hit in recent years, as many European consumers stopped spending on cosmetic dentistry during the financial crisis and rivals pushed ahead with cheaper options. Picture taken May 16. To match story NOBELBIOCARE-TURNAROUND/                         REUTERS/Mike Blake  (UNITED STATES - Tags: SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY HEALTH BUSINESS)

The supply of minerals such as gallium and indium are running short, halting our progress in technology. Image: REUTERS/Mike Blake

Adam Jezard
Senior Writer, Forum Agenda
Our Impact
What's the World Economic Forum doing to accelerate action on Industries in Depth?
The Big Picture
Explore and monitor how Mining and Metals is affecting economies, industries and global issues
A hand holding a looking glass by a lake
Crowdsource Innovation
Get involved with our crowdsourced digital platform to deliver impact at scale
Stay up to date:

Mining and Metals

The Fourth Industrial Revolution risks running out of steam because of a shortage of the essential elements needed to run it.

We are used to stories about the scarcity of metals that are needed to power the technology of the future, such as lithium, but there are other, rarer, elements without which mobile phones, DVD players, TVs, microwave communications and driverless cars may all grind to a halt.

Ensuring there are sufficient quantities of them could be essential if the high-tech future that governments and global companies keep promising is to happen.

Image: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA

Gallium, indium, hafnium and selenium

A periodic table, produced for a report by the American Chemical Society (ACS) in 2015, ranked 62 different elements based on their supply risk, environmental implications and vulnerability to shortages.

The names of some of the metals in the research may leave non-specialists scratching their heads. They include gallium, indium, hafnium and selenium, all of which are created as the byproducts of other mining and extraction processes.

Although their names may be unfamiliar to many, their uses are not.

  • Gallium, a byproduct of zinc and bauxite ores, is used in semiconductors – which provide 98% of commercial demand for the element – as well lasers in Blu-Ray players.
  • Indium, also found in zinc, is used in solar cells, LCD screens, computer chips, LEDs and solar panels.
  • Hafnium, a byproduct of zirconium, is found in nuclear reactor control rods, integrated microprocessor circuits and the liquid thruster nozzles of Apollo lunar spacecraft.
  • Selenium, an extract from ores such as copper, nickel and lead, is used in photocopiers, x-ray detecting machines and developing battery technologies.

But answers as to how we may cope without them were outlined almost a decade ago by a famous creator of wondrous, if occasionally dystopian, futures.

A sci-fi solution?

A 2008 study predicting the disappearance of gallium by 2017 prompted the science-fiction author Robert Silverberg to write: “All the hafnium [and gallium] will be gone by 2017 ... and another 20 years will see the extinction of zinc. Even copper is an endangered element since worldwide demand for it is likely to exceed available supplies by the end of the present century.”

Silverberg then outlined what states and companies needed to do to guarantee the high-tech future they envisage: “Solutions will be needed, if we want to go on having things like television screens and solar panels and computer chips. Synthesizing the necessary elements, or finding workable substitutes for them, is one obvious idea.

“Recycling these vanishing elements from discarded equipment is another. We can always try to make our high-tech devices more efficient, at least so far as their need for these substances goes. And discovering better ways of separating the rare elements from the matrices in which they exist as bare traces would help...”

Although the prediction that certain metals would disappear by 2017 was wrong – and the authors of the 2015 periodic table and research did not give any of them expiry dates – the truth is that depending on any of these elements could create problems in the delivery of Industry 4.0.

Balancing the risk factors

Two of the wider risks ACS highlighted are well known: one is the environmental hazards caused by the mining and extraction processes of metals, such as use of toxic mercury by artisanal miners to bind lumps of gold together.

As well as being harmful to natural ecosystems, mining also depends on fossil fuels that create carbon dioxide and other emissions that contribute to climate change and damage human health.

The other is how to maintain levels of vanishingly rare metals, such as gallium, that are only produced as byproducts of smelting and other industrial processes.

But a third is underreported, and it is this: even metals that boast high natural reserves, such as gold and platinum, as well as being among the most environmentally damaging to extract, are “geopolitically highly concentrated”. Their very abundance in places such as China and Africa – and scarcity elsewhere – could pose future problems.

As the ACS authors noted: “[In 1962] a civil war in the Democratic Republic of the Congo caused a significant, if temporary, decrease in the supply of cobalt... More recently, a decrease in exports of rare earth elements by China resulted in a variety of technological disruptions.

“The result has been numerous calls in recent years to better assess elemental resources and to determine which of them are ‘critical’, the aim being to minimize further disruptions to global and national technologies and economies”.

Have you read?
Don't miss any update on this topic

Create a free account and access your personalized content collection with our latest publications and analyses.

Sign up for free

License and Republishing

World Economic Forum articles may be republished in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International Public License, and in accordance with our Terms of Use.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone and not the World Economic Forum.

Related topics:
Industries in DepthNature and Biodiversity
World Economic Forum logo
Global Agenda

The Agenda Weekly

A weekly update of the most important issues driving the global agenda

Subscribe today

You can unsubscribe at any time using the link in our emails. For more details, review our privacy policy.

How these 5 steel producers are taking action to decarbonize steel production

Mandy Chan and Daniel Boero Vargas

June 25, 2024

About Us



Partners & Members

  • Sign in
  • Join Us

Language Editions

Privacy Policy & Terms of Service

© 2024 World Economic Forum