Economic Growth

Sharing salary data would help close the gender gap, right? Not necessarily

Facebook employees work in the design studio at the company's headquarters in Menlo Park, California March 2, 2012. Famous for a culture that glorifies the "hacker way," Facebook now talks of integrating "design thinking" into its products and has steadily beefed up its design studio. Design chief Kate Aronowitz dispatches designers who are paired with an engineer, a product manager and sometimes a researcher to conceive new products or improve features such as user profiles or messages. Picture taken March 2, 2012. To match Feature DESIGNERS-STARTUP/     REUTERS/Robert Galbraith  (UNITED STATES - Tags: SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY BUSINESS) - RTR30OBP

Women in tech early in their career are now asking for higher salaries, and getting them. Image: REUTERS/Robert Galbraith

Michael J. Coren
Reporter, Quartz

Hired had a problem. Women on the online hiring platform were consistently underbidding themselves. Hired, which lets technology workers post their preferred salaries so companies can interview them and extend offers, saw female applicants ask for lower salaries 69% of the time compared to men with comparable experience and skills.

Fixing that, thought Jessica Kirkpatrick, Hired’s lead data scientist, was a matter of education: give women data about average salaries in their field and they would correct their mistake. She helped design a feature giving candidates a custom range of average salaries based on their skills and experience.

Image: Hired

It didn’t go well.

After testing with thousands of candidates, the gender gap worsened. Women in the experimental group, newly aware of their salary distributions, placed themselves on the lower half of the salary curve. Men, with comparable skills and experiences, tended to assign themselves to the upper half. That led to a gender gap in preferred salaries that was even bigger than the gap among those who didn’t see the data at all (women in the experimental group asked for 9.3% less money than men compared to the control group which asked for 4% more money than men).

In retrospect, Kirkpatrick says the results don’t surprise her. In her first job as a data scientist, the former physicist—who holds an astrophysics PhD from the University of California-Berkeley—asked for a base salary near the lower end of her field. She eventually discovered men on her team with similar experience and job titles were paid $10,000 more. The income loss compounded over years and different jobs until arriving at Hired (which boosted her pay by 25%).

“I know that as a woman I am…likely to be more hesitant to put myself forward for opportunities where I don’t meet ‘all’ the qualifications—yet knowing this information doesn’t make it easier to advocate for myself or put myself forward for challenging opportunities,” Kirkpatrick wrote by email. “I still struggle with this on a regular basis. As a data-oriented person, I do find it easier to advocate for myself when I am armed with objective facts or statistics that can help back-up my requests. I also regularly put myself forward for opportunities that terrify me and where I don’t feel qualified, because I figure if I had the confidence and socialization of a man, I maybe wouldn’t have the same hesitations and self-doubt.”

Yet the experiment’s failure belied a promising trend Hired uncovered in a gender-wage gap report it released on April 4. The report was based on 120,000 interview requests and job offers from 8,000 companies in 2016.

Women in tech early in their career are now asking for higher salaries, and getting them. Analyzing the 2016 data, Hired found a sharp divergence between relative new and senior technology professionals. Female candidates with less than five years of work experience ask for higher salaries than their male counterparts, and those with less than one year of experience were the most confident, asking for an average of 4% more relative to comparable men. They also received 8% more in salary offers, equivalent to $1.08 in salary for every $1 offered to men. On average, that equated to more than $3,300 per year.

Yet that relationship reverses after six years. At that point, female candidates ask for about $5,000 less relative to comparable male candidates.

The reason is hard to isolate. Kirkpatrick suspects the more senior female job candidates may have seen lower salaries early in their career compounded over time, while new entrants are pushing for parity. A second possibility is that the demand for female tech companies to diversify their workplace has put female developers in high demand, and most of these new jobs are going to more junior candidates.

Hired is now exploring ways to give candidates salary data without widening the gender gap such as replacing a salary range with a single-number recommendation.

Don't miss any update on this topic

Create a free account and access your personalized content collection with our latest publications and analyses.

Sign up for free

License and Republishing

World Economic Forum articles may be republished in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International Public License, and in accordance with our Terms of Use.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author alone and not the World Economic Forum.

Stay up to date:

Economic Progress

Related topics:
Economic GrowthJobs and the Future of WorkEducation and Skills
Share:
The Big Picture
Explore and monitor how Economic Progress is affecting economies, industries and global issues
A hand holding a looking glass by a lake
Crowdsource Innovation
Get involved with our crowdsourced digital platform to deliver impact at scale
World Economic Forum logo
Global Agenda

The Agenda Weekly

A weekly update of the most important issues driving the global agenda

Subscribe today

You can unsubscribe at any time using the link in our emails. For more details, review our privacy policy.

Global economy responds to US presidential election and other economics news to read

Joe Myers

November 8, 2024

Sustainable trade could be an opportunity for Indonesia. Here’s how

About us

Engage with us

  • Sign in
  • Partner with us
  • Become a member
  • Sign up for our press releases
  • Subscribe to our newsletters
  • Contact us

Quick links

Language editions

Privacy Policy & Terms of Service

Sitemap

© 2024 World Economic Forum